West Maui Taxpayers Association
  • HOME
  • Olowalu Fire Station
  • WMTAPAC22
  • Affordable Housing
  • West Maui Lifesavers
  • Wall of Honor
  • Support WMTA
    • Membership - One Time Payment
    • Membership - Recurring Payment
    • Donations
    • Wills & Trusts
    • Charity Walk
  • Newsletter
  • Emergency Planning
  • News Blog
  • About Us
    • Goals & Objectives
    • Accomplishments
    • Board of Directors
    • WMTA vs WMIF
  • Contact
  • Subscribe

We Can't See It or Touch It, But We Can Tax It!

5/28/2018

 
WMTA Shares these commentaries, without taking a position unless otherwise noted, to bring information to our readers
​To view the archives of the Tax Foundation of Hawaii's commentary click here.
 ​​​​​​​

Weekly Commentary

For the Week of May 27, 2018

We Can't See It or Touch It, But We Can Tax It!
By Tom Yamachika, President
 
This week we look at HB 2416, a bill that applies Hawaii Use Tax to intangible property.

The Use Tax is a tax designed to protect our local businesses.  As a consumer, you often have a choice between buying a product from a local seller and one from somewhere out of state.  Our general excise tax applies to the local seller, but it might not apply to the foreign one.  Therefore, our law says that if you buy from the foreign seller and our GET in fact cannot apply to that sale (usually because the seller does not have a sufficient presence within Hawaii for it to be subject to Hawaii taxes), then you as the buyer will have to pay the same amount of tax to the State directly.

Most states that have a sales tax also have a use tax, for these reasons.   But those states’ taxes generally apply only to sales of goods, not to services or anything else.  Our tax applies to other things as well since there was a realization that local sellers of services needed to be protected.  Thus, in 2000 and 2001 the laws were amended to bring services and contracting within the scope of the Use Tax.  At the time, there was a lot of thought given to the issue because an “import” of services is tougher to see than, say, the import of a new car.

Here, this bill makes taxable an entire new category, and it’s unclear how much thought, if any, was given to the matter.  The bill sailed through the legislative process without much in the way of testimony.  Even our Department of Taxation was only able to say that the bill was consistent with its position on custom software (software specially written for a customer).  The relevance of the Department’s position is debatable because most states, including ours, consider custom software to be services, and we already apply Use Tax to services.

So what, if anything, is the bill trying to tax?  License fees, franchise fees, and royalties perhaps?  Certainly, a franchise to run a particular branded business in Hawaii or a license to show a particular television show here, for example, are intangible property in Hawaii.  But there is already a Hawaii Supreme Court case, In re Heftel Broadcasting Honolulu, Inc., 57 Haw. 175, 554 P.2d 242 (1976), cert. denied, 429 U.S. 1073 (1977), saying that when that kind of intangible property is created, the franchise owner or license owner has to pay GET, even though the owner may not have any other connection with or physical presence in Hawaii.  Now, the way the Use Tax is designed is that if the seller is legally obligated to pay GET, Use Tax is not imposed on the buyer.  The buyer won’t know if the seller paid the GET, so liability for Use Tax doesn’t depend on whether the seller actually paid the GET.

So what is really happening?  Is the objective to scare people into paying taxes they don’t owe?  Consider what happened to the automobile dealerships in the late 1960’s and through the 1970’s when they were paying Use Tax, thinking that they were importing automobiles from an unlicensed seller, and the Department was getting GET from the manufacturers unknown to the dealerships.  The story is described in another Hawaii Supreme Court case, In re Aloha Motors, Inc., 69 Haw. 515, 750 P.2d 81 (1988), but the court had to give effect to the statute of limitations and held that the dealerships could get a refund of three years of Use Tax, although there had been double payments for a decade.  Eventually, special legislation was passed in 1990 (Act 297) to relieve the dealerships from this injustice.

The Use Tax Law is already confusing.  Rather than mindlessly adding to the confusion with new taxes that haven’t been tried anywhere else, a comprehensive revamp of the Use Tax Law is needed.  At least make it so people have a reasonable chance of understanding the existing law.

Comments are closed.
    Picture

    RSS Feed


    If you wish to further discuss blog posts, please contat our office directly or contact us via Contact page.

    Categories

    All
    Affordable Housing & Homelessness
    Board
    Capital Improvements
    Charity Walk
    Commentaries
    Community Events
    Community Resources
    CON
    COVID 19
    Educational
    Emergency Planning
    Health & Safety
    HHARP
    Housing
    Infrastructure In West Maui
    In The News
    Kapalua Airport Runway Lights
    Kapalua Coastal Trail
    Lahaina Bypass
    Legislature Newsletters
    LLC
    Long Range Transportation Plan 2040
    Long-Range Transportation Plan 2040
    Makila
    MAUI CANCER CENTER
    Maui Cancer Center Llc
    Maui County
    Maui County Budget
    Maui County Dept Of Environmental Management
    Maui County - Dept Of Water
    Maui Destination Management Plan
    Press
    Public Safety In West Maui
    Real Property Tax
    Recycling Info
    TAT
    Tax
    Tourism
    Traffic & Roadways
    Transportation
    Video
    Vote
    Voting
    West Maui Community Plan
    West Maui Hospital
    West Maui Skate Park
    WMTA Annual Meeting
    WMTA Breakfast Events
    WMTA Candidates Night
    WMTA Disaster Preparedness
    WMTA Fundraisers
    WMTA Hot Topics
    Wmta Hot Topics Replay
    WMTA Membership
    WMTA PAC
    WMTA Sunset Sail
    WMTA Whale Watch

Quick Links: 

Home

News

About Us

Wall of Honor

Newsletter

Support WMTA
Emergency Planning

Contact

Copyright © 2021
Photo used under Creative Commons from wolfsavard
  • HOME
  • Olowalu Fire Station
  • WMTAPAC22
  • Affordable Housing
  • West Maui Lifesavers
  • Wall of Honor
  • Support WMTA
    • Membership - One Time Payment
    • Membership - Recurring Payment
    • Donations
    • Wills & Trusts
    • Charity Walk
  • Newsletter
  • Emergency Planning
  • News Blog
  • About Us
    • Goals & Objectives
    • Accomplishments
    • Board of Directors
    • WMTA vs WMIF
  • Contact
  • Subscribe