The Feds Gave You a Break? Now We, the State, Can Turn the Screws?

WMTA Shares these commentaries, without taking a position unless otherwise noted, to bring information to our readers
​To view the archives of the Tax Foundation of Hawaii's commentary click here. ​​​​​​​


Weekly Commentary

For the Week of April 15, 2018

 
The Feds Gave You a Break? Now We, the State, Can Turn the Screws?
By Tom Yamachika, President
 
It’s not often that State lawmakers express their justification for imposing taxes in terms other than “We need the money to fund essential services and programs.”  But how about this?  The following language is from an actual bill:  

"The legislature finds that the federal government has significantly raised the threshold for the federal estate tax.  The federal estate tax grants an exemption of $5,490,000 per individual and up to $10,980,000 for a surviving spouse; provided that the surviving spouse elects to use portability of the predeceased spouse's exemption on the predeceased spouse's estate tax return.  Estates valued at less than these amounts are exempt from paying federal estate taxes.  The recently enacted Public Law No. 115-97, originally introduced in Congress as the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, doubles the threshold to approximately $11,180,000 and $22,360,000, respectively, and will result in a reduction in federal estate tax revenues.  According to Internal Revenue Service data, twenty-one estates in Hawaii paid a total of $23,471,000 in federal estate taxes in 2015.

The legislature further finds that these changes to the federal estate tax provide the State with an opportunity to benefit Hawaii residents.  By amending Hawaii's estate tax thresholds and rates, the State can capture some of the money that certain residents will no longer be required to pay to the federal government and redirect that money to the State."

This, by the way, is from HB 207, Senate Draft 1. 

As it now exists, the bill would jack up the Hawaii estate tax by adding a new top tax rate of 20% to be applied to taxable estates over $10 million.  It would also hike the Hawaii conveyance tax on purchases or sales of condominiums or single-family residences valued at $2 million or more, and there the tax would increase between 66% and 220% depending on the value of the unit being sold.

The bill as the House passed it in 2017 looks nothing like the current bill.  Surprise, surprise, this bill is another victim of the much-hyped “gut and replace” technique.  What does that mean?  The only thing about a bill that can’t be changed during its journey through the Legislature is its title, and under the Hawaii Constitution, the contents of a bill must relate to its title.  Therefore, if a legislative committee has before it a bill with a broad title like “Relating to Taxation,” it can amend the bill by gutting it and replacing its entire contents with something very different.  This bill as the House passed it, for example, was an income tax bill relating to the low-income householder renters’ credit.  But because its title is “Relating to Taxation,” the income tax contents can be deleted and replaced with hikes in the estate and conveyance taxes. 

Now, the Senate adopted some rules that sound like they wanted to curb the “gut and replace” technique.  Senate Rule 54(2) says, “The fundamental purpose of any amendment to a bill shall be germane to the fundamental purpose of the bill.”  In practice, however, gut-and-replace is still alive and well, and a technique in the playbook of many of the House and Senate committee chairs.  So, as our legislative session finally winds down, there will be lots of surprises such as bills previously thought dead being resurrected by incorporating their contents into other bills.

It ain’t over till it’s over, folks!